The fallibility of chip and pin

It was introduced back in 2004 and heralded as a fraud-smashing new approach to safely paying for goods and services. Like an impenetrable rock.

The swish-swoosh of elaborate signatures – because we all thought the more complex the style, the harder it would be to forge – became a traditional gesture. The strip on the back of cards for our names still exists, but the signature we put on it, is to some extent, redundant.

By 2005 it was viewed as a groundbreaking step forward, evidently doing its job and doing it well. The UK Payments Administration Ltd, which was then known as the Association for Payment Clearing Services, reported that chip and pin had cut plastic card fraud by 13 per cent.

It was validation.

However, flaws in the system have been identified. Last year seemed to be a particular milestone in changing perceptions. The conversation in the information security and risk management industry about the shortcomings of chip and pin was becoming louder.

Chip and pin was meant to do away with skimming – where cards are swiped. In March of this year, Italian specialists explained that EMV (Europay, MasterCard and VISA) cards “talk to” payment terminals, which fraudsters can now read if they install skimming devices on such outlets.

They can even do this on a pin terminal, after which a “clone card” can be produced. The myth that chip and pin is a rock of security has been broken.

More worryingly, researchers at Cambridge discovered that it was possible for perceptive criminals to commit fraud without needing a pin.

They dubbed this the man-in-the-middle attack. Naturally, they didn’t release too much information, but the basic premise follows.

For one, the fraudsters are au fait with the intricate details of the chip and pin system – call it insider knowledge if you will. Secondly, they must have external hardware capable of pulling off such a scam – which can be done remotely.

“Essentially what it does is to exploit a flaw in the chip and pin system,” Dr Saar Drimer, who was part of the research, told the BBC at the time.

“It makes the terminal think the correct pin has been entered, and the card thinks the transaction was authorised with a signature.”

Of course, like any security system, nothing is absolutely fool proof, but chip and pin was brought in to be a radical alternative. In some ways, with the weaknesses identified, it has lost its ability to sit smugly at the top of the security tree. It’s now just another payment system, prone to attack.

What do you think? Post your comments below and let us know.

Our accreditations & Partners

  • REC Member
  • VTC - Virtual Technology Cluster
  • RANT Events
  • Bloom Nepro
  • YPO
  • Crown Commerical Service
  • Disability Confident
  • ISO 9001
  • Armed Force Covenant
  • Cyber Essentials Plus
  • ISO 27001

Thanks

Success

Thanks

Success

Thank you for signing up to the acumin alerts.

Send CV

Send us your CV and have our recruiters match you to the ideal opportunities

Do you already have an account with us?

Log in

Want to have an account with us?

Register

Want to just send us your CV?

Upload only doc, docx, odt, pdf format file.

By submitting your registration and CV to us you are agreeing to join our database and to be contacted about relevant jobs industry communications. Please read our terms of business for more information.

Password reset

If you need a reminder for your password, fill out the field below

Log in

Access your account to edit your contact details, job alerts or to upload a new CV

Thank you

Success

Thank you for successfully uploading your CV.

Acumin Alerts

Success

Thanks for registering for Acumin alerts.

Acumin Alerts

Unfortunately your CV could not be uploaded

Please make sure your CV is one of the following file types: doc, docx, odt, pdf, rtf

Acumin Spam

Unfortunately your submission has been declared spam. Please try again.

Vacancy

Success

Thank you for submitting your vacancy.

Register

Create an account to register your contact details, sign up for job alerts and upload your CV

Success

Thanks for registering for Acumin alerts. To get the most out of Acumin's service why not register with us?

Upload only doc, docx, odt, pdf format file.
- Practitioner
- Commercial

I agree to the terms and conditions and to be contacted by recruiters:

I agree to receive marketing communications relevant to my job search:

I agree to receive Jobs By Email for the following professions:
- Business Continuity Management
- Counter Fraud
- Cyber Security
- Executive Management
- Governance & Compliance
- Information Security & Risk Management
- Penetration Testing & Digital Forensics
- Sales and Marketing
- Sales Engineering
- Security Management
- Technical Security
- Information/Risk Assurance
- Identity Management
- Application Security
- Security Architecture
- Dev/Sec Ops
- DV & SC Cleared Jobs
- Programme & Project Management
- CISO/CSO

Submit a Vacancy

Use the form below to submit a vacancy